CO129-142 - Public Offices & Others - 1869 — Page 73

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

71

being that of the work done in the interval between detection and the inquest) and, in short, that the whole expenditure of the ... was managed by some individual.

It further results from the facts in evidence that in the Koung tee and the pansi Cinigration depots of Hong Kong, all the sick amongst the great numbers of Chinamen, almost all being persons whatever brought, by methods, from the neighbouring Empire into that Colony, are trusted to be treated by Mr. Catchwell and those under him, pretty much at their discretion; that they are pronounced by them to be fit for removal to a miserable house called the "Tung Wah Hospital", and that the condition of patients there is such as to exclude almost the chance of their coming out alive.

What that mortality may be does not exactly appear. The enquiry not having found the tables of admissions, discharges, and deaths during any given period. But at least 73 per cent of the emigrants received appear to have perished within its walls: a mortality not only proven by Leffan Marker's evidence (the only living Maker examined) who acknowledges continuous employment there to the extent of from four to six daily, but also from ...

If your Lordship doubts that this frightful mortality is chiefly, if not entirely, due to the circumstance above discussed of the unfeeling, sordid, and revolting neglect and abandonment of those poor creatures by their foreign holders or owners, the positive testimony of the medical gentlemen, Dr. Murray and Dr. Cochrane, of the Inspector of Brothels, and of the other Official Witnesses will remove that doubt. It would be improper for the Association to reproduce the foul details of the annexed report in those particulars, and they gladly forbear. If the argument a cognite ad ignotum permitted it to be permissible after reading that part of the Report.

Those witnesses saw the dying and the dead wallowing together in floods of filth and covered with vermin in their beds, "shut in" and, in some cases, in "locked cells", without egress. They had to rouse the former from their stupor before they could determine whether they were alive. He did say, and finding by a ...

Page 72 (expected to be three lines at the bottom, but not present in the original snippet)

As there are no three lines at the end indicating "Page 72", the original text likely continues without a page break at this point.

Edit History

2026-05-20 10:43:41 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
71 being that of the work done in the interval between detection and the inquest) and, in short, that the whole expenditure of the ... was managed by some individual. It further results from the facts in evidence that in the Koung tee and the pansi Cinigration depots of Hong Kong, all the sick amongst the great numbers of Chinamen, almost all being persons whatever brought, by methods, from the neighbouring Empire into that Colony, are trusted to be treated by Mr. Catchwell and those under him, pretty much at their discretion; that they are pronounced by them to be fit for removal to a miserable house called the "Tung Wah Hospital", and that the condition of patients there is such as to exclude almost the chance of their coming out alive. What that mortality may be does not exactly appear. The enquiry not having found the tables of admissions, discharges, and deaths during any given period. But at least 73 per cent of the emigrants received appear to have perished within its walls: a mortality not only proven by Leffan Marker's evidence (the only living Maker examined) who acknowledges continuous employment there to the extent of from four to six daily, but also from ... If your Lordship doubts that this frightful mortality is chiefly, if not entirely, due to the circumstance above discussed of the unfeeling, sordid, and revolting neglect and abandonment of those poor creatures by their foreign holders or owners, the positive testimony of the medical gentlemen, Dr. Murray and Dr. Cochrane, of the Inspector of Brothels, and of the other Official Witnesses will remove that doubt. It would be improper for the Association to reproduce the foul details of the annexed report in those particulars, and they gladly forbear. If the argument a cognite ad ignotum permitted it to be permissible after reading that part of the Report. Those witnesses saw the dying and the dead wallowing together in floods of filth and covered with vermin in their beds, "shut in" and, in some cases, in "locked cells", without egress. They had to rouse the former from their stupor before they could determine whether they were alive. He did say, and finding by a ... Page 72 (expected to be three lines at the bottom, but not present in the original snippet) As there are no three lines at the end indicating "Page 72", the original text likely continues without a page break at this point.
Baseline (Original)
71 bing that of the work done in the interval: between detection and the inquest) and, in short that the whole expenditure of the managed by thoot plux AVCVO defrayed Dome individual. It further results from the facts in ondence that in the Koung tee and the panou Cinigration depicts of flong kong all the sick amongst great- Members of Chinamen, almost alt being persone whatarever brought, by methods, from the neighbouring Empere into that Colony, are truded to treated by Mr. Catchwelk and those change, pretty much at thei divoration; that pronounced by them in A ccloco to be meuble house called the ( toze Hospital and that the Mlation of pumality there is such exclude almost the chance the chance of auf are sent off to the clead coming out alive 4 us Av. What that Martio may be dves & not exactly apperty. The perry not having found the tobuls of admissions, discharger and deaths during any given pered But at least 73 per lent of the Eigrants received appear to have pariched within its walls: mortality but also prom ے ہیں leffen Markers evidence (the only liffin Maher exammed) who- acknowledges continous emplopment at there to the extent of from toffure daily, bar one to have B four doubt F any If your Lordship that this fughtful mortality is chiefly Mather entirely due to the circumstance above debcuted of the unfecting, serded, and revolting neglect curd aboundonment of those poor creatures by their foreign holders o owners the positive kotunony of the alledical Gentlemen Drelhuray and Dbochrane, of the Ino peder of Brotheles, and of the other Officeal Witnesses will remove that doubt. It would be improper for the Association to Meproduce the foul details of the annexed report in those particulare and they gladly forbear If the argument a cognite ad ignotum permitted it to permissible after rendurg that part of the Report. Those witresors saw the diping w ever tok and the dead, wallowing together in floods of filth and covered with Vermon in their beds," shut in" and, in "locked cello, without egress. of the pune of their prare < potion may be forced not only four what had been send already but. They brast to g'teuse the former from there stupor before they could determine whether M R T they EX. VVORE" VETOXY WIT me (ay of my visit, melt t EST VOUWCIT has seen the weak was alive. He did sy and finding by a U conle gust
2026-05-20 10:43:41 · Baseline
View content

71

bing that of the work done in the interval: between detection and the inquest) and,

in short that the whole expenditure of the managed by thoot

plux

AVCVO

defrayed

Dome individual.

It further results from the facts in ondence that in the Koung tee and the panou

Cinigration depicts of flong kong all the sick amongst great- Members of Chinamen, almost alt being persone

whatarever brought, by methods, from the neighbouring Empere into that Colony, are truded to treated by Mr. Catchwelk and those change, pretty much at thei divoration; that

pronounced by them

in

A

ccloco

to be meuble house called the ( toze Hospital and that the Mlation of pumality there is such exclude almost the chance

the chance of auf

are sent off to the clead

coming out alive

4

us Av.

What that Martio may be dves &

not exactly apperty.

The

perry

not having

found the tobuls of admissions, discharger

and

deaths during any

given pered

But at least 73 per lent of the

Eigrants received appear to have pariched

within its walls:

mortality

but also prom

ے ہیں

leffen Markers evidence

(the only liffin Maher exammed) who- acknowledges continous emplopment

at

there to the extent of from toffure daily,

bar

one to

have

B

four

doubt

F

any

If your Lordship that this fughtful mortality is chiefly

Mather entirely due to the circumstance above debcuted of the unfecting, serded, and revolting neglect curd aboundonment of those poor creatures by their foreign holders o owners the positive kotunony of the alledical Gentlemen Drelhuray and Dbochrane, of the Ino peder of Brotheles, and of the other Officeal Witnesses will remove that doubt. It would be improper for the Association to Meproduce the foul details of the annexed report in those particulare and they gladly forbear If the argument a cognite ad ignotum permitted it to

permissible after rendurg that part of the Report. Those witresors saw the diping

w ever tok

and the dead, wallowing

together in floods of filth

and covered with

Vermon in their beds," shut in" and, in

"locked cello, without egress.

of the pune of

their

prare

<

potion may

be forced not

only four what had been send already

but.

They brast to g'teuse the former from there stupor before they could determine whether

M

R

T

they

EX.

VVORE" VETOXY WIT me (ay of my visit, melt t EST VOUWCIT has seen the weak

was alive. He did sy and finding by a

U conle gust

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.